Skip to content
London Cash Project

The Failure of the 28-Point Peace Proposal for Ukraine: Why Peace Negotiations Continue to Stumble

Europe felt a moment of respite on Monday, as the tension caused by the announcement of a new 28-point plan for achieving ceasefire appeared – momentarily – to have been stabilised. A Washington representative spoke of "significant advancement" after bilateral negotiations in Geneva. On Monday night, Russian leadership made its retaliation: another massive barrage of aerial bombardment on Kyiv.

The Rhythm of Peace Talks and Military Action

The succession of contrasting events captured the grim essence of the recent timeframe. By day, diplomatic battles are waged: optimistic declarations are released from different nations. Considerable effort is expended on containing specific proposals. By night, Russian leadership forcefully demonstrates the world that, for them, war remains the main instrument for achieving "resolution".

After-Dark Attacks

As the offensive developed into the early hours of Tuesday, the immediate reality of Ukraine's vulnerability was exposed. Ukraine is capable of detecting projectile deployments from across the border, a capacity provided through up-to-date information. From witness perspectives, Ukrainian air force fighter jets that had been scrambled to engage hostile cruise missiles roared overhead – modern combat jets delivered to Ukraine by NATO members.

Moments later, Kyiv's missile defense engaged: several firings targeted at a hostile projectile. This was a modern interception technology at work, probably provided by partner states. Every firing jolts you unexpectedly, shaking the windows. The instant of fear quickly gives way to resigned acknowledgment: perhaps the incoming missile won't cause damage this time, preventing destruction from ruin and further power outages.

Ongoing Risks

Not long after, a large-caliber weapon fired at a aerial vehicle in the vicinity, part of a rapid response unit – most likely allied-provided weaponry. Unfortunately, the bullets missed the opposing UAV – it continued its flight toward its destination.

With pauses, this continued until dawn. Kyiv awoke to the daybreak reports: seven people killed, destruction and heating outages in many homes as a result of the nocturnal offensive. As always, everyone still maintained normal activities – living the war. But those entire period demonstrated Ukraine's vital need on external assistance – a dependence that regional partners are clearly incapable to replace in the immediate future.

Failed Diplomacy

The 28-point plan from Washington sparked intense emotion, debate and profound anxiety – and momentarily shifted focus from Ukraine's major integrity crisis in years. Yet, we have experienced comparable situations, after prior negotiation attempts and multilateral gatherings.

Every new approach from Washington unfolds according to the same pattern: a negotiation push against Ukraine, which Kyiv, with other European capitals, manages to fend off. They manage the tension but never actually secure success. This trend will, undoubtedly, endure.

Strategic Calculations

It is convenient to criticize specific actors of repeatedly advocating Kremlin's demands. But that does not seem to be the complete picture. American leadership works based on a principle familiar among international relations experts: you cannot win at the negotiating table what you have lost on the battlefield. The White House believes that it is unfeasible to force Russia to relinquish the territory that it presently holds in Ukraine's south or east.

The issue is that while acknowledging this situation, Washington does nothing to discourage Russia, through diplomacy or military means, from thinking that the situation will not shift further in its advantage in the near future.

Opposing Positions

Therefore, Russian leadership is confident that duration works to their advantage – that Ukraine and its partners are approaching exhaustion. Their incentive to accept conditions that does not give them the maximum possible gain is almost completely absent. There may be many attempts to achieve ceasefire, but they will persist as long as Russia's government remains completely certain in the outcome.

On the contrary, Ukrainian leadership believes that Ukraine can still endure, slowly losing civilians and areas but preventing a complete military breakdown until situations evolve in its favour.

Present Conditions

Factually, there are no actual prerequisites for a ceasefire. Now, subjective factors are entering the equation: political desires to mediate resolution and secure international recognition, and Ukrainian leadership's dual difficulties – on one hand, not to distance important partners, and on the other, to unite the population around the country's interests against any initiative Kyiv finds unacceptable, so that their attention does not move to internal issues. And although their objective will now be considerably more difficult after latest incidents, it remains very improbable that this will modify their basic position.

These opposing factors are guiding negotiations.

Summary and Prospects

It took a only one week to eliminate the proposed articles of the most recent proposal. Aggressive and erratic handling of the matter by US administration, resistance by Ukraine and the other European countries, along with pacifying measures of representatives, and finally, latest revelations, all served their function.

While new proposals based on old ideas are forthcoming, Kyiv, London and other European capitals should reach an essential realization: Ukraine and Europe will only be able to fend off negotiation assaults from Washington that are founded on Moscow's terms and demonstrate specific hesitation to modify developments, if they stand together and enhance their military capacity at a significantly accelerated rate. If they do, neither political nor armed coercion will be able to overcome them. In the meantime, Ukraine's capability to repel nightly air assaults will, for the predictable period, mainly require continued Western support.

CH
About the author

Catherine Hood

Elena is a London-based personal finance expert with over a decade of experience helping urban professionals grow their wealth.

London Cash Project

Type to search articles.